Estimating Post-Treatment Effect Modification With Generalized Structural Mean Models∗
نویسندگان
چکیده
In randomized controlled trials, the evaluation of an overall treatment effect is often followed by effect modification or subgroup analyses, where the possibility of a different magnitude or direction of effect for varying values of a covariate is explored. While studies of effect modification are typically restricted to pretreatment covariates, longitudinal experimental designs permit the examination of treatment effect modification by intermediate outcomes, where intermediates are measured after treatment but before the final outcome. We present a generalized structural mean model (GSMM) for analyzing treatment effect modification by post-treatment covariates. The model can accommodate post-treatment effect modification with both full compliance and noncompliance to assigned treatment status. The methods are evaluated using a simulation study that demonstrates that our approach retains unbiased estimation of effect modification by intermediate variables which are affected by treatment and also predict outcomes. We illustrate the method using a randomized trial designed to promote re-employment through teaching skills to enhance self-esteem and inoculate job seekers against setbacks in the job search process. Our analysis provides some evidence that the intervention was much less successful among subjects that displayed higher levels of depression at intermediate post-treatment waves of the study.
منابع مشابه
Conditioning on Post-treatment Quantities with Structural Mean Models∗
In this paper, I demonstrate how structural mean models (SMMs) can be used to estimate quantities based on post-treatment variables. SMMs are semiparametric models where the parameters of the model or models correspond to meaningful functions of expected potential outcomes for subjects actually exposed to the treatment. SMMs provide a flexible framework for estimating causal effects with noncom...
متن کاملHistory-adjusted marginal structural models for estimating time-varying effect modification.
Much of epidemiology and clinical medicine is focused on estimating the effects of treatments or interventions administered over time. In such settings of longitudinal treatment, time-dependent confounding is often an important source of bias. Marginal structural models (MSMs) are a powerful tool for estimating the causal effect of a treatment using observational data, particularly when time-de...
متن کاملInvited Commentary Invited Commentary: Effect Modification by Time-varying Covariates
Marginal structural models (MSMs) allow estimation of effect modification by baseline covariates, but they are less useful for estimating effect modification by evolving time-varying covariates. Rather, structural nested models (SNMs) were specifically designed to estimate effect modification by time-varying covariates. In their paper, Petersen et al. (Am J Epidemiol 2007;000:000–00) describe h...
متن کاملUsing Cold Plasma Technology as a Method for the Structural Modification of Corn Starch and Its Functional Assessment in Food Models
Background and Objectives: Cold plasma is used as an innovative solution in production and distribution of healthy and high-quality foods. Objectives of this study were to use cold plasma technology as a method for the structural modification of corn starch and its functional assessment in food models. Materials & Methods: Starch granules were treated with plasma with two various gases in the ...
متن کاملGeneralized Structural Mean Models for Evaluating Depression as a Post-treatment Effect Modifier of a Jobs Training Intervention∗
In randomized controlled trials, the evaluation of an overall treatment effect is often followed by effect modification or subgroup analyses, where the possibility of a different magnitude or direction of effect for varying values of a covariate is explored. While studies of effect modification are typically restricted to pretreatment covariates, longitudinal experimental designs permit the exa...
متن کامل